Skip to main content

Table 2 The design of the studies included in this meta-analysis and characteristics of their participants

From: A Meta-Comparison of the Effects of High-Intensity Interval Training to Those of Small-Sided Games and Other Training Protocols on Parameters Related to the Physiology and Performance of Youth Soccer Players

Reference (year)

Subjects /age (years)

Total number of sessions/duration/duration of one intervention session/duration of one control session

Intervals of exercise (number and duration)

Interval intensity

Duration of rest

Intensity of exercise during rest

VO2peak/max before the intervention (mL·kg−1 · min−1)

VO2peak/max after the intervention (mL·kg−1 · min−1)

Change in VO2max (%)

Findings concerning the HIIT

Los Arcos et al. (2015)1 [27]

15/16

12/6 weeks/

25 min/25 min

HIIT

MAS ↔;

CMJ ↔

3 × 4 min

90–95% HRmax

3 min

50–60% HRmax

n.i.

n.i.

n.i.

SSG

3 × 4 min

n.i.

3 min

n.i.

n.i.

n.i.

n.i.

Faude et al. (2014)2 [29]

19/17

8/4 weeks/

22 min/36 min

HIIT

IAT ↑; CMJ ↓

DJ ↔; Vpeak ↓

Lacmax ↔

5-m, 10-m, 30-m sprint ↔;

CinD ↔

2 × (12–15 × 15 s)

40% above IAT

10 min/15 s

n.i.

n.i.

n.i.

n.i.

SSG

4 × 4 min

n.i.

4 min (PR)

n.i.

n.i.

n.i.

n.i.

Faude et al. (2013)2 [4]

20/16

12–15/5.5 weeks/

33 min/47 min

HIIT

IAT ↑; CMJ ↓

DJ ↓; Vmax ↔

2 × (12–15 × 15–30 s)

25–40% above IAT

10 min (AR)/15–30 s

n.i.

n.i.

n.i.

n.i.

HVT

30–60 min

80–95% IAT

–

–

n.i.

n.i.

n.i.

Sperlich et al. (2011)1 [10]

19/13

13/5 weeks/

28.8 min/57.3 min

HIIT

VO2max ↑;

1000-m run ↑; 20-m, 30-m, 40-m sprint ↑;

DJ, SJ, CMJ ↔

4–15 × 30 s–4 min

90–95% HRmax

1–3 min

50–60% HRmax

55.1 ± 4.9

58.9 ± 4.7

+ 6.9

HVT

6–30 min

50–70% HRmax

–

–

55.3 ± 4.3

56.4 ± 3.7

+ 2.0

Hill-Haas et al. (2009)1 [11]

19/15

14/7 weeks/

66 min/66 min

HIIT (intervals, RSA, COD, sprints)

VO2max ↔; YYIRTL1 ↑; MSFT ↔;

TTE ↔; 5-m, 20-m sprint ↔; RSA ↔

–

–

–

n.i.

60.2 ± 4.6

61.4 ± 3.5

+ 2.0

SSG

2–3 × 6–13 min

n.i.

1–3 min

n.i.

59.3 ± 4.5

58.9 ± 5.5

− 0.7

Impellizzeri et al. (2008)1 [12]

21/18

11/4 weeks/

25 min/25 min

HIIT

VO2max ↑;

LSPT total performance ↔;

LSPT total performance fatigued ↑

4 × 4 min

90–95% HRmax

3 min (AR)

n.i.

~ 56.6

~ 58.9

~ + 4

TT

–

–

–

–

~ 57.7

~ 57

~ − 1.2

Impellizzeri et al. (2006)1 [28]

29/17

16/8 weeks/

n.i./n.i.

HIIT

VO2max ↑; IAT ↑; RE at LT ↔; VO2 at LT ↑;

% VO2max at LT ↑;

Ekblom’s test ↑

4 × 4 min

90–95% HRmax

3 min

60–70% HRmax

59.7 ± 4.1

60.2 ± 3.9

+ 0.8

SSG

4 × 4 min

90–95% HRmax

3 min

60–70% HRmax

61.4 ± 4.6

61.8 ± 4.5

+ 0.7

Siegler et al. (2003)1 [30]

34/16

30/10 weeks/

n.i./n.i.

Functional HIIT (sprinting and jumping)

LIST ↑; 20-m sprint ↑; VJ ↔

3–5 × 4–6 reps.

100%

n.i.

n.i.

n.i.

n.i.

n.i.

VOT

n.i.

n.i.

n.i.

n.i.

n.i.

n.i.

n.i.

Helgerud et al. (2001)1 [13]

19/18

18/8 weeks/

28 min/30 min

HIIT

VO2max ↑; IAT ↑

↔; VO2 at LT ↑;

10-m, 40-m sprint ↔;

VJ ↔

4 × 4 min

90–95% HRmax

3 min

50–60% HRmax

58.1 ± 4.5

64.3 ± 3.9

+ 10.7

TT

–

–

–

–

58.4 ± 4.3

59.5 ± 4.4

+ 1.9

  1. ↑ significant positive effect; ↓ significant negative effect; ↔ no significant effect
  2. 1Controlled pre-post-design
  3. 2Cross-over study design
  4. AR active rest, CinD change-in-direction run, CMJ countermovement jump, DJ drop jump, HRmax maximal heart rate, HVT high-volume training, IAT individual anaerobic threshold, Lacmax maximal blood lactate concentration, LIST Loughborough Intermittent Shuttle Test, LSPT Loughborough Soccer Passing Test, LT lactate threshold, MAS maximal aerobic speed, MSFT multistage fitness test, n.i. not indicated, PR passive rest, Reps repetitions, RE running economy, RSA repeated sprint ability, SJ squat jump, SSG small-sided game, TT technical training, TTE time to exhaustion, Vmax/peak maximal velocity during incremental step test, VJ vertical jump, VO2max maximal oxygen uptake, VOT volume-oriented training at low intensities, VT ventilatory threshold, YYIETL1 Yo-Yo intermittent endurance test level 1, YYIRTL1 Yo-Yo intermittent recovery test level 1