Topic | Item # | Checklist item | References |
---|---|---|---|
Exercise selection, performance, and training parameters (a flowchart is recommended) | |||
Exercise selection | 1a | Provide the name and movement description of every exercise and report the exercises performed in each training session | Kassiano et al. [34] |
1b | Provide enough information for readers to know whether the exercises were free-weight or machine-based, and unilateral or bilateral | Free-weight vs machine-based Heidel et al. [35] Unilateral vs bilateral Moran et al. [36] | |
1c* | Report the range of motion of each exercise | Schoenfeld and Grgic [37] Pallarés et al. [38] | |
Training frequency and length | 2 | Report the training frequency and length (e.g., 3 sessions/week × 12 weeks) | Schoenfeld et al. 2016 [39] Ralston et al. [40] Schoenfeld et al. [41] Grgic et al. [42] Ralston et al. [43] Schoenfeld et al. [44] Androulakis-Korakakis et al. [45] Baz-Valle et al. [46] Cuthbert et al. [47] Baz-Valle et al. [48] |
Warm-up and movement descriptions | 3 | Report the content of the warm-up and transition (minutes) before the main resistance exercise training | Ribeiro et al. [49] |
Intensity | 4a* | Report the absolute training intensity in % 1RM (1 repetition max), #RM, or % #RM (e.g., 75% 1RM, 10RM, or 90% 5RM) | Tschopp et al. [50] Raymond et al. [51] Csapo and Alegre [52] Schoenfeld et al. [53] Schoenfeld et al. [54] Hansen et al. [55] Grgic [56] João et al. [57] Souza et al. [58] Lacio et al. [59] Lopez et al. [60] Refalo et al. [61] Carvalho et al. [62] |
4b | Report the subjective exercise intensity, e.g., the rate of perceived exertion (RPE) | Zhang et al. [63] Hickmott et al. [64] | |
4c | If applicable, report the relative training intensity. For example, if a participant performs 5 repetitions of squat with 90 kg and their 5RM is 100 kg, then the relative intensity is 90 kg ÷ 100 kg = 90% | NSCA handbook [3] | |
Number of repetitions and the set endpoint | 5a* | Report the number of repetitions per set | Androulakis-Korakakis et al. [45] Hackett et al. [65] |
5b* | Report whether the participants were asked to train to failure or not | Davies et al. [66] Cerqueira et al. [67] Vieira et al. [68] Grgic et al. [69] Vieira et al. [70] | |
5c | Clearly define the set endpoint. For example, the set could be defined to have ended when the participants determined that they could not complete the next repetition (i.e., self-determined repetition maximum). See Steele et al. [27] for detail | Steele et al. [27] | |
Exercise sequence and the structure of sets | 6a | Exercise sequence: Report the sequence of all resistance exercises. If the session included multiple sets, report whether the sequence was traditional (e.g., squat set 1 → squat set 2 → deadlift set 1 → deadlift set 2) or circuit (e.g., squat set 1 → deadlift set 1 → squat set 2 → deadlift set 2). If other training methods were used, such as super-set, complex and contrast training, and multiple-joint to single-joint, report the exercise sequence in detail | Krzysztofik et al. [71] Nunes et al. [72] |
6b | Structure of set: If an alternative set structure (i.e., cluster set and rest redistribution) was used, report the method in detail. Describe the intra-set and inter-repetition rest intervals if applicable | Krzysztofik et al. [71] Latella et al. [73] Jukic et al. [74] Davies et al. [75] Jukic et al. [76] | |
6c | Number of sets: Report the number of sets per exercise per training session | Durall et al. [77] Bågenhammar and Hansson [78] Krieger [79] Krieger [80] Ralston et al. [40] Schoenfeld et al. [41] Ralston et al. [81] Androulakis-Korakakis et al. [45] Baz-Valle et al. [46] Baz-Valle et al. [48] | |
Rest interval between sets and exercises | 7* | Report the rest interval between sets and exercises | Grgic et al. [82] Grgic et al. [83] da Silva et al. [84] |
Movement tempo | 8a* | Report the tempo of resistance exercises in each phase, including but not limited to the durations in eccentric, transition, and concentric phases and the duration between each repetition. If no introduction was provided, state so | Tschopp et al. [50] Schoenfeld et al. [85] Davies et al. [86] Hackett et al. [87] da Rosa Orssatto et al. [88] Krzysztofik et al. [71] |
8b | If applicable, describe how the tempo was set | ||
Movement velocity | 9 | Report the movement velocity if recorded | Larsen et al. [89] Zhang et al. [63] Liao et al. [90] Hickmott et al. [64] Orange et al. [91] Zhang et al. [92] |
Attentional focus | 10* | If applicable, describe the attentional focus strategy, e.g., external focus | Grgic et al. [93] Grgic and Mikulic [94] |
Concentric or eccentric-focused training | 11a* | If non-traditional resistance training (with both concentric and eccentric phases) was used, report the phase emphasized | Roig et al. [95] Douglas et al. [96] Schoenfeld et al. [97] Molinari et al. [98] Buskard et al. [99] Krzysztofik et al. [71] |
11b | If applicable, describe the method used to emphasize the concentric/eccentric phase of muscle action, e.g., a longer duration of eccentric phase per repetition | ||
11c | If the accentuated eccentric loading method was used (i.e., the load was higher during the eccentric phase than during the concentric phase), report the method used to attain the supramaximal eccentric load | ||
Drop set | 12 | If applicable, report the number and structure of the drop sets | Krzysztofik et al. [71] |
Inter-set intervention | 13* | If an inter-set strategy was used (instead of having typical rests between sets), report the method | Latella et al. [100] |
Training program and progression | |||
Progression | 14a | Describe in detail the decision rule(s) used for determining exercise progression | Adapted from CERT item 7a |
14b | Describe in detail how the exercise program progressed | Adapted from CERT item 7b | |
Autoregulation method | 15 | If autoregulation training was used, e.g., autoregulatory progressive resistance exercise, rating of perceived exertion, and velocity-based training programs, report the method | APRE program Larsen et al. [89] Zhang et al. [63] |
RPE program Larsen et al. [89] Zhang et al. [63] Hickmott et al. [64] | |||
VBT program Larsen et al. [89] Zhang et al. [63] Liao et al. [90] Hickmott et al. [64] Orange et al. [91] Zhang et al. [92] | |||
Programming/ periodization | 16 | Report the resistance training program (i.e., manipulation of parameters such as intensity and volume). If used, report the model of programming/periodization, e.g., daily undulating and weekly undulating methods | Harries et al. [101] Grgic et al. et al. [102] Williams et al. [103] Grgic et al. [104] Moesgaard et al. [105] |
Exercise setting | |||
Equipment | 17 | Describe in detail the type of exercise equipment used | Adapted from CERT item 1 |
Location | 18 | Describe the setting in which the exercises were performed | Adapted from CERT item 12 |
Supervision | 19 | Report whether the resistance training was supervised or not. If the resistance training was supervised, report the ratio of instructor to participants | Adapted from CERT item 4 |
Time | 20 | Report the time of training (e.g., 10:00–11:00) | Grgic et al. [106] |
Blood flow restriction | 21a | If blood flow restriction was used, describe the pressure modality: 1. Intermittent or continuous (minutes) 2. Pressure (#mm Hg or % of arterial occlusion pressure) 3. Cuff width (cm) 4. Where the pressure was applied 5. The inflator device | Domingos and Polito [107] Lixandrão et al. [108] Krzysztofik et al. [71] Centner and Lauber [109] Cuyul-Vásquez et al. [110] Ferlito et al. [111] Grønfeldt et al. [112] Cerqueira et al. [113] Cerqueira et al. [67] de Queiros et al. [114] Liu et al. [115] Nitzsche et al. [116] Rodrigo-Mallorca et al. [117] Koc et al. [118] |
21b | If blood flow restriction was used, report how, when, and at what position the arterial occlusion pressure was determined | ||
Elastic resistance training | 22 | If applicable, report the method and equipment used | Lopes et al. [119] |
Inertial resistance training | 23 | If applicable, report the method and equipment used | Vicens-Bordas et al. [120] |
Training in hypoxia | 24 | If applicable, report the setting in which the training occurred | Ramos-Campo et al. [121] |
Planned vs. actual training | |||
Adherence | 25 | Describe how adherence or fidelity to the exercise intervention was assessed/measured, e.g., via drop-out rate and attendance rate | Adapted from CERT 16a |
Compliance and deviation | 26 | Describe the extent to which the intervention was delivered as planned. Report the deviation from the original exercise protocol | Adapted from CERT 16b |