Skip to main content

Table 5 Summary of studies evaluating aerobic exercise amount and intensity effects on markers of insulin sensitivity and glucose homeostasis

From: Differential Effects of Amount, Intensity, and Mode of Exercise Training on Insulin Sensitivity and Glucose Homeostasis: A Narrative Review

Study

n

Population

Training type/intervention length

Groups

Measure

Results

DiPietro et al. [10]

25

BMI < 30 kg/m2

 > 60 yrs

Women

9-month aerobic intervention

Vigorous Intensity: 300 kcal/session at 80% peak V̇O2

Moderate Intensity: 300 kcal/session at 65% peak V̇O2

Control/Low Intensity: 45 min/session at 50% peak V̇O2

Hyperinsulinemic–euglycemic clamp

Fasting Glucose

No change in exercise groups

Fasting Insulin

No change in exercise groups

Whole-Body Glucose Utilization Rate at 40 mU

Significant increase in Vig. Group

Basal Hepatic Glucose Production

Significant decrease in Mod. Group

Coker et al. [12]

21

BMI: ≥ 26 to < 37 kg/m2

65 to 90 yrs

12-week aerobic intervention

Vigorous Intensity: 1000 kcal/week at 75% peak V̇O2

Moderate Intensity: 1000 kcal/week at 50% peak V̇O2

No Exercise Control

Insulin-stimulated Glucose Disposal

Significant increase in Vig. Group

Non-oxidative Glucose Metabolism

Significant increase in Vig. Group

Ross et al. [54]

300

Abdominal obesity:

Men WC > 102 cm or

Women WC > 88 cm

35 to 65 yrs

24-week aerobic intervention

No Exercise Control

Low Amount/Moderate Intensity: Women: 180 kcal/session and Men: 300 kcal/session at 50% peak V̇O2

High Amount/Moderate Intensity: Women: 360 kcal/session and Men: 600 kcal/session at 50% peak V̇O2

High Amount/Vigorous Intensity: Women: 360 kcal/session and Men: 600 kcal/session at 75% peak V̇O2

Oral glucose tolerance test

2-h Glucose

Significant difference in change between High/Vig vs. Control

Significant difference in change between High/Vig vs. Low/Mod

Glucose AUC

Significant difference in change between High/Vig vs. Low/Mod

Insulin AUC

Significant difference in change between High/Vig and High/Mod vs. Control

Matsuda Index

Significant difference in change between High/Vig and High/Mod vs. Control

Significant difference in change between High/Vig vs. Low/Mod

Malin et al. [55]

31

Average BMI: 32.1 kg/m2

Average age 61.4 yrs

Prediabetes

Nonsmoking

Physically inactive

13-day aerobic intervention

Moderate Intensity/ Continuous Exercise: 60 min each day at 70% peak HR; rest on day 7

Vigorous Intensity/ Interval Exercise: 60 min each day alternating 3-min intervals at 90% peak HR followed by 50% peak HR; rest on day 7

Oral glucose tolerance test

Glucose AUC

Significant decrease in both groups

Insulin AUC

Significant decrease in both groups

Skeletal Muscle Disposition Index

Significant increase in both groups (early and total-phase)

Oral Minimal Model (Skeletal Muscle Insulin Sensitivity)

Significant increase in both groups

  1. AUC, area under the curve; BMI, body mass index; HR, heart rate; WC, waist circumference