Skip to main content

Table 3 Characteristics of HIIT interventions performed as a part of physical education (intra) or in another connection (extra) in school

From: Effects of High-Intensity Interval Training in School on the Physical Performance and Health of Children and Adolescents: A Systematic Review with Meta-Analysis

Setting

Study

Intervention

Participants (n)

Age (years)

Type of exercise

Intensity of exercise

Characteristics of the sessions

Duration of study and individual sessions

Frequency of sessions (per week)

Baseline VO2peak [mlmin−1·kg−1 or l/min−1]

%-change VO2peak

Outcome: HIIT versus control

Intra-PE

Baquet et al. [30]

HIIE:

503

w = 12.7

m = 12.8

Running + Scheduled PE

100–120% MAS

n = 10

W = 10 s

R = 10 s

W:R = 1

3 sets; 3-min rest

10 wks

25–33 min HIIE

2 with 1 h HIIT and 2 h scheduled

PE

n.i

n.i

%BF(m&w) ↑

D7↑

MAS↑

SLJ↑

SHR↔

  

CON:

48

w = 13.0

m = 13.5

Scheduled PE

n.i

n.i

10 wks

2

n.i

n.i

 
 

Camacho et al. [6]

HIIT:

18

11.06

Running (sprints)

89.93% HRmax and maximal sprints

n = 1

W = 20 s

R = 20–60 s

W:R = 0.3–1

3–6 sets

8 wks

2.66–8 min

3

46.1 ± 5.7

n.i

FM↔

TFM↔

  

CON:

16

11.29

Running

65–75% HRmax

n = 1

W = 2.66–8 min

R = 0

8 wks

2.66–8 min

3

45.6 ± 6.6

n.i

 
 

Engel et al. [7]

HIIT:

39

11.9

Running and game playing

90–100% vmean and all-out sprints

n = 4–10

W = 10 s-4 min

R = 20 s-3 min

W:R = 0.5–1.33

6 wks

20 min

2

n.i

n.i

BMI↑

6-min Run↑

20-m Sprint↑

SLJ↑

  

GAT:

46

11.4

Running and game playing

65–85% vmean

n = 1–4

W = 5 min-25 min

R = 0–5 min

6 wks

30 min

2

n.i

n.i

 
 

Martin et al. [8]

HIIT:

18

16.9

Running (sprints)

87% HRmax

and maximal effort

n = 4–6

W = 30 s

R = 30 s

W:R = 1

4 sets

7 wks

16–24 min

3

47.1 ± 6.3

4.2

VO2max↔

FG↔

FINS↑

SRP↔

HOMA-IR↔

  

SPE:

19

16.8

Scheduled PE

n.i

n.i

7 wks

60 min

3

46.1 ± 7.3

-6.9

 

Extra-PE

Baquet et al. [39]

HIIT:

33

9.5

Running

100–130% MAS

n = 5–10

W = 10–20 s

R = 10–20 s

W:R = 1

1–4 sets; 3 min rest

7 wks

30 min

2

43.9 ± 6,2

8.2

%BF↔

HRmax↔

MAV↑

VO2peak↑

  

CON:

20

9.9

Scheduled PE

n.i

n.i

7 wks

n.i

46.2 ± 8.5

-2.0

 
 

Baquet et al. [41]

HIIE:

36

9.7

Running + Scheduled PE

100–130% MAS

n = 5–10

W = 10–20 s

R = 10–20 s

W:R = 1

1–4 sets; 3-min rest

7 wks

30 min

2 + scheduled

PE

n.i

n.i

%BF↔

MAV↑

SLJ↑

SHR↔

  

CON:

36

9.7

Scheduled PE

n.i

n.i

7 wks

n.i

n.i

n.i

 
 

Baquet et al. [24]

HIIT:

22

10.0

Running

100–190% MAS

n = 5–10

W = 10–20 s

R = 10–20 s

W:R = 1

1–4 sets; 3-min rest

7 wks

25–35 min

(60 min)

3 + (2 scheduled PE)

51.6 ± 2.8

4.8

BMI↔

HRmax↔

MAV↑

VO2peak↑

  

CTG:

22

9.8

Running

80–85%

MAS

n = 1

W = 6–20 min

R = 0

1–4 sets; 5 min rest

7 wks

18–39 min

(60 min)

3 + (2 scheduled PE)

50.1 ± 6.0

7.0

 
  

CON:

19

9.3

Scheduled PE classes

n.i

n.i

7 wks

2

50.6 ± 6.1

-1.8

 
 

Gamelin et al. [40]

HIIT:

22

9.8

Short intermittent runs

100–190% MAV

n = 5–20

W = 5–30 s

R = 15–30 s

W:R = 0.3–1.5

1–4 sets

7 wks

30 min

3

51.6 ± 2.8

4.8

HRmax↔

M↑

MAV↑

VO2peak↑

  

CON:

16

9.3

n.i

n.i

n.i

7 wks

30 min

3

49.9 ± 4.8

-2.4

 
 

Mc Manus et al. [43]

HIIT:

10

10.4

Cycling

All-out sprints

n = 7

W = 30 s

R = 2.45 min

W:R = 0.18

8 wks

20 min

3

45.5 ± 3.4

11.4

HRmax↔

VO2↑

VO2peak↑

  

CTG:

10

10.4

Cycling

80–85% HRmax

n = 1

W = 20 min

R = 0 min

8 wks

20 min

3

47.0 ± 6.5

7.8

 
  

CON:

15

10.5

Habitual

PA

n.i

n.i

8 wks

n.i

44.7 ± 6.5

1.8

 
 

Nourry et al. [42]

HIIT:

9

9.7

Running + Scheduled PE

100–130% MAS

n = 10

W = 10–20 s

R = 10–20 s

W:R = 1

4 sets; 3 min

8 wks

ca. 30 min

2

37.4 ± 7.3

15.5

%BF↔

FVC↑

HRpeak↔

Ppeak↑

VO2max↑

  

CON:

9

10.3

Scheduled PE

n.i

n.i

8 wks

n.i

36.8 ± 7.8

-0.54

 
 

van Biljon et al. [10]

HIIT

29

11.1

Running/Sprinting

 > 80% HRmax

n = 10

W = 60 s

R = 75 s

W:R = 0.8

5 wks

23 min

3

14.1 ± 7.3

45.4

BMI↔

DBP↓

FG↓

RHR↓

SBP↓

VO2peak↑

 

MICT

29

11.1

Walking

65–70% HRmax

n = 1

W = 33 min

R = 0

5 wks

33 min

3

11.6 ± 5.1

27.6

 
  

HIIT & MICT

27

11.1

Running + Walking

65– > 80% HRmax

n = 10

W = 60 s

R = 75 s

W:R = 0.8

&

n = 1

W = 33 min

R = 0

5 wks

23–33 min

3

(9 sessions HIIT/6 sessions MICT)

17.8 ± 9.8

28.1

 
  

CON

24

11.1

No training/intervention

12.6 ± 6.8

26.19

     
  1. #: ↑ = significant increase. ↓ = significant decrease. ↔  = no change. %BF = percentage body fat. W:R = work-to-rest ratio. BMI = body mass index. CTG = continuous training group, CON = control group. D7 = maximal distance covered during a 7-min running test, DBP = diastolic blood pressure. FG = fasting level of blood glucose, FINS = fasting level of blood insulin, FM = fat mass, FVC = forced vital capacity. GAT = aerobic endurance training. h = hours, HIIE = high-intensity interval exercises, HIIT = high-intensity interval training, HOMA-IR = homeostatic model of assessment for insulin resistance. HRmax = maximal heart rate, HRpeak = peak heart rate. M = mass, m = metre, MICT = moderate-intensity continuous training, min = minute, MAS = maximal aerobic speed, MAV = maximal aerobic velocity. n = number, n.i. = not indicated. PA = physical activities, PE = physical education, Ppeak = peak power. R = rest, RHR = resting heart rate. SLJ = standing long jump, SBP = systolic blood pressure, SHR = 10 × 5 m shuttle run, SPE = standard physical education, SRP = shuttle run performance. TFM = trunk fat mass. vmean = mean running speed, VO2 = oxygen uptake, VO2max = maximal oxygen uptake, VO2peak = peak oxygen uptake. W = work
  2. w = women
  3. m = men