Skip to main content

Table 3 Summary of the main data from the studies included

From: The Role of Technology in Adherence to Physical Activity Programs in Patients with Chronic Diseases Experiencing Fatigue: a Systematic Review

Study

Chronic disease

Number of participants

Control group

Timeline (weeks)

Mean age (years)

Sex M/F

Program’s goal

PA outcome

Adherence

Primary outcome of each study

Secondary outcomes of each study

Backman et al. [51]

Breast and colorectal cancer

39

Yes

10

54

8/31

10,000 steps

Step counts

 90% week 1,  85% week 10a

Adherence to PA intervention

HRQoL, body composition and blood markers

Benzo et al. [52]

COPD

12

No

8

> 40

Not specified

12 min walk

Walking minutes

89 ± 0.22%

Program feasibility

WAI-SR

Gary et al. [53]

HF

24

Yes

12

60

12/12

Individualized: from 30 to 60 walking minutes, 3 times per week

Walking minutes, daily steps

83%

CS-PFP10

Muscle strength, HRQoL, functional capacity, disease severity levels

Hooas et al. [44, 50]

COPD

10

No

156

55

5/5

Individualized

Training sessions

69.1% year 1, 40.5% year 2, 13.9% year 3 (9/10)b

Adherence

System Usability Scale

Mendoza et al. [49]

COPD

50

Yes

13

68

33/17

Personalized

Step counts

80±31% week 4, 85 ± 26% week 8, 81 ± 22% week 13c

Daily step counts

Exercise capacity (6MWT), health status (SGRQ, CAT)

Moy et al. [54]

COPD

27

No

13

72

27/0

Personalized

Step counts

90.39% at baseline, 104.82% week 12a

Daily step counts

General health status, MMRC dyspnea score, Bristol knowledge, exercise self-efficacy

Pinto et al. [55]

Breast cancer survivors

43

Yes (but not analyzed)

12

53

0/43

Personalized

Exercise minutes, step counts

88.37% week 1, 55.81% week 12

Adherence

Exercise self-efficacy

  1. HRQoL Health Related Quality of Life, COPD Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease, WAI-SR Working Alliance Inventory‐Short Revised, HF Heart Failure, CS-PFP10 Continuous Scale Physical Functional Performance test, 6MWT 6-Min Walk Test, SGRQ Saint George’s Respiratory Questionnaire, CAT Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease Assessment Test, MMRC Modified Medical Research Council
  2. acalculated by authors
  3. b at 3 year follow-up there were only 9 patients
  4. cdata requested and obtained from corresponding author